Safety Glazing at standard storefront systems

For some reason, I can never really seem to get my head around 2406.3.

The window schedule excerpts below are from a small office building we are working on, specifying standard aluminum storefront systems at the exterior. The code official seems to be requiring tempered glass at all of the lower panels, as you can see denoted by the (T) symbol. Here is what I cannot figure out, where would that be required? These windows are within 36" of a walking surface. But, according to 2406.3.7, to be required as safety glazing they must meet all of the conditions:
1. greater than 9 s.f.
2. lower edge is less than 18" a.f.f.
3. top edge is greater than 36" a.f.f.
4. walking surface within 36".

The standard design detail for our building has the lower horizontal mullion at 2'-2" a.f.f. Doesn't this mean that neither the lower or upper panels must be tempered?
Obviously, the panels subject to the door swings and stair requirements of 2406.3.5 & 6 would be tempered. But these elevations below are from standard open office spaces.

Attachments

Photos (1)
Original Post
One more question while I'm at it:

It also seems that the requirement for 2406.3.6 (door swing) requires the adjacent glazing to be tempered but states "and where the bottom exposed edge of the glazing is less than 60 inches above the walking surface". In the excerpt below, you can see that the building official has us using tempered glass for the glazing above and adjacent to the door too. This seems to be in excess of the requirements, correct?

Attachments

Photos (1)
All the subitems of Section 2406.3, item 7, need to apply. Since the exposed top edge of those bottom panes are not greater than 36 inches, and the area of those panes are not greater than 9 sq. ft., then they do not need to be of safety glazing.

Also, regarding your second post, only those panes within 24 inches of the vertical edges of the door, but have bottom edges not less than 60 inches, do not need to be of safety glazing. Only those areas indicated in red below are required to have safety glazing. Refer to the IBC Code and Commentary.

Attachments

Photos (1)
Ron, thank you very much for confirming what I was thinking. Although I have a number of code books (including Ching's visual guide), I don't believe we have the commentary in the office and will order it right away.
Likes (0)
×
×
×
×
×